Italy: Parliament Adopts Anti-Semitism Law Amid Political Divisions Over IHRA Definition
Italy has officially approved a new law aimed at strengthening the fight against anti-Semitism, marking a significant development in the country's efforts to address hostility towards Jewish communities. However, the legislation has exposed deep political disagreements over how anti-Semitism should be defined, particularly in relation to criticism of Israel.
The legislation received final approval from the Chamber of Deputies on November 17, with 147 votes in favour, 93 against and five abstentions. It had previously passed through the Senate on March 4, completing the parliamentary process under the government led by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni.
At the centre of the new framework is the adoption of the operational definition of anti-Semitism established by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), together with its 11 illustrative examples. The definition is intended to provide public authorities with a common reference for identifying and addressing anti-Semitic behaviour.
The IHRA Definition at the Heart of the Debate
The legislation incorporates examples covering various forms of anti-Semitism, including certain attempts to delegitimise Israel, comparisons between Israeli government policies and those of Nazi Germany, and holding Jewish people collectively responsible for decisions made by the Israeli state.
However, the IHRA framework also makes an important distinction: criticism of Israel, when comparable to criticism directed at other countries, should not automatically be considered anti-Semitic.
This distinction has become one of the most controversial aspects of the Italian debate. Opponents of the legislation argue that some of the examples could be interpreted too broadly, potentially blurring the boundary between anti-Semitic rhetoric and legitimate political criticism of Israeli policies.
Opposition Parties Split Over the Legislation
Although the governing coalition strongly supported the measure, the parliamentary vote revealed significant divisions within the opposition.
Centrist political formations, including Italia Viva and Azione, backed the legislation. By contrast, the Democratic Party, the Five Star Movement and the Green-Left Alliance largely opposed it.
The disagreement also extended within the Democratic Party itself. Several representatives from its reformist wing, including former minister Piero Fassino, abstained rather than follow their party's position.
Amnesty International Italy also raised concerns about the possible implications of the legislation for freedom of expression, particularly regarding public debate on Israel and its government policies.
Supporters of the measure dismissed these concerns, arguing that adopting a recognised international framework is necessary to improve the protection of Jewish communities and strengthen institutional responses to anti-Semitism.
A Preventive Approach Without New Criminal Penalties
Despite the political controversy, the legislation does not introduce additional criminal offences or establish new penalties. Instead, its primary objective is to reinforce public policies focused on prevention, education, awareness and the protection of Jewish institutions.
By providing authorities with a shared framework, the law seeks to improve the identification of anti-Semitic incidents and encourage more coordinated institutional action.
The urgency of these measures is underlined by the figures cited by the Associated Press. Italy recorded 963 anti-Semitic incidents in 2025, more than twice the number reported in 2023.
The adoption of the law therefore represents both a political milestone and the beginning of a broader debate about how European democracies can combat anti-Semitism while safeguarding freedom of expression and the right to political criticism.
-
23:00
-
21:00
-
14:00
-
13:30
-
13:00
-
08:15
-
07:45
-
22:00
-
18:30