German Federal Court clarifies refund claims on current account fees
Banks and savings institutions in Germany can no longer assume their customers’ consent to fee increases simply because customers do not object within a set period. This principle was firmly established by the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) in a landmark ruling that invalidated so-called "consent fiction" clauses in bank contracts.
These clauses, common in general terms and conditions, treated contractual changes—such as price hikes or account model adjustments—as accepted if customers failed to object within a deadline. For years, this silent consent model was standard practice among banks and savings banks.
However, in April 2021, the BGH ruled in favor of the Federation of German Consumer Organisations (vzbv), declaring the clause used by Postbank invalid. The court found that the clause was overly broad and unfairly disadvantaged customers by presuming consent without explicit approval (BGH, judgment of April 27, 2021, case no. XI ZR 26/20).
Although the ruling directly concerned Postbank, it sent a strong signal across Germany’s banking sector, where many institutions employed similar contractual terms. This was reinforced on March 27, 2024, when the Berlin Higher Regional Court, in a model declaratory action, declared unilateral fee increases by Berliner Sparkasse invalid.
As a result, customers who were charged fees under these invalid clauses may be entitled to reclaim those fees and reverse contract changes. However, they should be mindful of statutory limitation periods for claims.
Consumer advice centers now provide interactive sample letters to help customers request refunds from their banks efficiently.
This clarification by the BGH marks a significant step in consumer protection, ensuring that banks must obtain clear consent for fee changes rather than relying on presumed acceptance.
Lire aussi
Latest News
- Ayer 17:10 Spanish PM apologizes after senior official resigns amid corruption probe
- Ayer 16:20 GCC Reaffirms Commitment to Morocco's Sovereignty Over Sahara
- Ayer 15:50 Naver collaborates with Nvidia and Nexus to establish AI data center in Morocco
- Ayer 15:20 Historic agreement reached between the UK and EU over Gibraltar
- Ayer 15:20 Morocco reaffirms its African commitment as separatist entity excluded from FOCAC
- Ayer 14:43 Iran's Revolutionary Guard Calls for Halt on WhatsApp Sharing Amid Rising Tensions
- Ayer 14:15 Tesla establishes Moroccan subsidiary, signaling Africa expansion